Merchant of Venice

Antonio vs Shylock

Antonio vs Shylock image
The main assumption in 'The Merchant Of Venice' is that Shylock is the villain, although in plain perception he does seem to be the antagonist there is reason to consider the possibility that Antonio can be just as villainous as him. Throughout the play Shylock is constantly put under an evil light while Antonio is portrayed as the victim but in reality Antonio has proven that he has his fair share of villainous moments. A common trait that they both share is religious discrimination, using each others beliefs and stereotyping them to bring each other down. They also show their merciless and unfair selves with the bond which they created together, showcasing their reactions when the contract is broken. In addition they also both desire different things that make their characters seem stubborn, greedy and selfish.

Religious discrimination is a constant theme in 'The Merchant Of Venice' which also applies to the villainous nature of Shylock and Antonio. They are on opposing religions and during the time period which the play is set, there was a social ranking based on religion, Antonio is a Christian so he has a higher social rank than Shylock who is a Jew. Due to the clear division between the two religions, in the play Antonio feels superior to Shylock, he has no shame in talking down to him or making fun of his beliefs. Throughout the story, Shylock on multiple occasions brings up the wrongs that have been committed against him, yet characters such as Antonio still feel that it is appropriate to "call ...[him] misbeliever" and "spit upon ...[his] Jewish gaberdine". Despite how much prejudice Antonio has displayed from his nature, he isn't the only one who shows signs of discrimination. Shylock has become a victim to Antonio's bigotry however, there is evidence of Shylock doing the same to Antonio. Regardless of the amount of money Shylock has, he will still receive less status than Antonio. As a Jew he doesn't have many rights and is looked down upon however, he uses this in his advantage. Through the ridicule which Shylock receives from Antonio, Shylock has made an assumption that all Christians are inequitable people and has built stereotypes on their religion to bring them down. He often uses stories from the bible and compares them to the way which he acts to get what he wants and to put down the Christian religion. Shylock has gained a hatred towards the religion and he no longer trusts or appreciates a Christian which he has shown with phrases such as "I hate him for he is a Christian".

The bond between Antonio and Shylock is a very vital and famous factor in 'The Merchant Of Venice' because it is the basis for the plot and the different story lines in the play. The bond was a contract that Antonio and Shylock had created so that Antonio could borrow money for three months to help Bassanio. After three months Antonio had to pay back the money or Shylock could take "an equal pound of ...[his] fair flesh" closest to the heart from Antonio. Antonio instantly agrees since his ships were supposed to come back with great fortunes a month before the the bond ends. However, there was news going around claiming that the ships had been miscarried. Due to the news Antonio had no choice but to accept the consequences. Up until this moment Shylock and Antonio didn't have any interaction with each other but when it came to the day of the trial there were sides of both characters that made their innocence and their guilt questionable. When considering the bond Shylock is perceived as a merciless monster. He wouldn't take mercy on Antonio no matter how much the court begged and often used the law as an excuse for his own hatred on Antonio. The scene seems to put Shylock in a villain position while making Antonio the victim however, that is no necessarily true. Although it can't be denied that Shylock is quite merciless from how insistent he was to carry out the penalty, it should be considered that he hasn't necessarily done anything wrong. He does not need be merciful, therefore although what he is doing is not morally right, lawfully he is innocent. Antonio on the other hand has a complicated involvement in the bond. The whole reason Antonio even signed the bond was to help Bassanio so it is hard to picture him in a position where he is doing wrong, however, during the trial, Antonio had no right to beg for mercy. He is the one who went to Shylock and asked for the bond and he is the one who convinced Shylock to agree to the bond with the words "But lend it rather to thine enemy, who if he breaks, though mayst with better face exact the penalty" which means that Antonio actually told Shylock to carry out the penalty if the bond requirements are not met. Therefore he has no right, to be begging for mercy or to let the blame fall onto Shylock.

Antonio and Shylock show their nature and their values is many different ways but some can be hard to interpret such as their desires. Their hopes and wants aren't necessarily just written on the page, they are spread across the whole play and by identifying them, the kind of people Antonio and Shylock are can be established. Shylock's desires aren't hidden too much since there is a common theme in the things which he cares about most, which is money. Shylock even desires wealth over his daughter, Jessica. When she ran away with Lorenzo, she took a sum of Shylock's money and a number of his precious jewels. After Shylock discovers what has happened he doesn't seem to care that his daughter ran away, he only cares about the fact that she went with a Christian and that she took his precious fortune. When he sent people out to find Jessica all he said was, "find the girl! She hath the stones upon her and the ducats!" He doesn't seem worried about his daughter in anyway he just wants the fortune he lost and couldn't care less about Jessica. Antonio is quite different, he doesn't care too much about his wealth but he does care about his religion. There are many other things which Antonio cares about, such as Bassanio but his commitment and appreciation for Christianity brought out a side of him which is quite questionable. It is no secret that Antonio and Shylock constantly discriminate each other because of their religions but Antonio is actually quite different from Shylock in the terms of how they discriminate. Shylock just simply doesn't want anything to do with Christians, as unfair as it is to stereotype all Christians, Shylock doesn't make the first move when it comes direct inequity. He fights back but he doesn't start the fight. Then there is Antonio he is insistent on bringing Shylock down. At the end of the trial scene where Antonio should have been the one facing consequences, the tables turned and Shylock found himself begging for mercy. Antonio then went as far as to give Shylock only two options either "he presently become a Christian" or he will die. In the end Shylock did choose to become a Christian but he was stripped of all his morals and was forced into a lifestyle which he never believed in. 

Overall, Antonio and Shylock have both had moments where they seem to be the villain. Shylock was the antagonist of the play so naturally he is perceived as the villain however, Antonio has shown that despite the fact that he is one of the protagonists he can still be a character with just as much evil inside him. They have both shown different but effective ways in which they discriminate each other for their religions. They also have two different perspectives of how the bond was made while also having different reactions to when it was broken indicating how the themes of morals and law influence the characters nature. Finally there was their desires, each of them have at least one thing which the desire in the wrong way causing them to show that both of them are like villains.

Conclusion image

The bond

The bond is the basis of the story and is the cause of many of the problems concerning mostly the characters Antonio and Shylock.

Ducats

The ducats represent the importance of wealth for Shylock and how money is also one of the big themes in 'The Merchant Of Venice'.

Scales

The scales represent multiple things, the power comparison between the two religions, the trial and just acceptance of different cultures and religions.

I BUILT MY SITE FOR FREE USING